A girl in college falls into a love triangle and has to chose.
“Are you ready for college sweetie? It’s move in day!” said my mom.
“I was born ready!” I exclaimed.
“That’s the spirit!” said my dad.
I moved everything into my room, but my roommate wasn’t there yet. Who was it going to be? Was she going to be nice or mean? Kind or rude? Pretty or ugly? All these thoughts raced around my head as I moved in.
After I moved all my stuff in and my parents left, I was sitting in my room enjoying the silence when there was a knock at the door. I went over and answered it and there was this beautiful girl standing there.
“Hi I’m Erika and I’m your roommate. I can’t wait to spend the next year with someone as cool as you!!!”
Well, all my questions were answered. She was a nice, kind, and beautiful girl.
We spent the rest of the day just talking and getting to know each other. I instantly fell in love with her but she could never know.
I fell deeper in love with her when I saw her change. She had the most amazing breasts and the most beautiful legs and a perfect figure. I was fully in love with my roommate.
From that first day, we spent every second together. We were like best friends but I wanted to be more. There were times where I wanted to tell her how I felt but I stopped myself. It was only the first week of school and we had the whole year together. Best to not ruin it on the first week.
At first, we had regular school days filled with classes and homework. That all changed one night.
While Erika and I were in our dorm room, we got a knock at the door. It was my friend Grace from my high school. I introduced her to Erika during the first week of school.
“Hey guys. I’m throwing a party tonight and you’re both invited.”
“No thanks I’m good.” I replied.
“Come on Elise we’re both 18 now. Time to cut lose! It’ll be fun.” Erika chimed in.
“I’m not a big partyer. I never have been to one so might as well not start now.”
“It will be fun. I’m not taking no for an answer.” Grace pressed on.
“Fine lets do it.” I finally relented.
“YAY! PARTY!!! Be at my dorm at 7:00.”
“Ok. See you soon!”
I was so nervous and I knew that this party would make a first impression on a lot of people that I didn’t know and some of them might even be friends of mine one day. I had to look good so I wore a short skirt and a nice tank top with a very revealing bra. I wanted to look sexy but also conservative. Erika agreed with my outfit and we headed out.
We got to Grace’s door and knocked and she answered.
“Ready for the best night of your lives?”
“I don’t know about that but I’m ready to have fun and relax a bit.” I answered.
“Come on in!” and she invited us in.
We were the last ones there. All the girls were sitting on the floor just chatting and drinking their drinks.
“Ok now that everyone is here, its time for the special ingredient for all your drinks.” And she pulled out a big bottle of vodka.
“None of us are old enough to drink though.” I said.
“No but we’re all 18 so we are adults so we might as well drink adult drinks. Don’t worry Elise we will all be ok.”
“Alright I guess you’re right.”
“This is going to be a great night!” exclaimed Erika.
“Your damn right it is.” Another girl said.
“Is it only girls tonight?” I asked.
“Yeah this is just girl time tonight. Plus, we are playing some crazy drinking games and we don’t want guys to be involved in those.”
“Good point.” I responded.
We all started to get to know each other and just chatted while getting drunk. Then it was time to party.
“Alright girls. I hope you’re not all too drunk yet because it time for DRINKING GAMES!!!!! CIRCLE UP BITCHES!!!!!” she basically screamed.
We all circled up.
“We have two games and they are in a specific order. First up is “Never have I ever”. It goes like this. You say something you’ve never done and if someone has done it they drink. Get it?”
“We got it.” We answered in unison.
We started and there were some really simple ones and some people were drinking. When we were all a little bit drunker that’s when the weird ones came out.
“Never have I ever had sex.” I said and they all drank except Erika.
Next was Erika. She thought about for a second and what she said shocked me to my core.
“Never have I ever kissed a girl.” Grace and I were the only ones who drank. I didn’t know Grace was bisexual or lesbian. Maybe it was from another drinking game or a dare. Anyways, I knew I had to be Erika’s first kiss from a girl.
We played a few more rounds and then Grace called it.
“That’s it. Time for the next game. I know this might be weird but we’re all drunk enough for it to not be. Spin the bottle.”
YES YES YES!!! This is perfect I thought. I might be able to kiss Erika and she would never suspect anything because of the game.
“Erika you’re up first!”
She spinned. Please be me! Please be me! But sadly it landed on a girl named Charlotte across the room. They kissed for about 3 seconds and then broke the kiss.
“Guess I have kissed a girl now.” And we all laughed.
“Your turn Elise.” Please be Erika I said in my head over and over as it spinned. I thought it was about to land on her but it spinned past her and landed on Grace.
“FUCK ME” I screamed in my head.
“Scoot over here girl!” she said slyly to me.
I moved over to her and gave her a quick kiss.
Everyone started to say, “WHOAH NO NO NO.”
“What did I do? I kissed her!”
“For less than a second. New rule. Has to be for 3 seconds at least but it can be longer if you’re both feelin’ it.” Said Grace.
“Ok fine. Rules are rules.”
I kissed her again but this time it felt different. I felt something awaken inside me. Before I could define it the kiss was over. Was I attracted to Grace?
It went around the circle and went back to Erika. I had butterflies. It was spinning and spinning and spinning and I couldn’t believe my luck when it landed on me.
I was literally jumping for joy in my head. I was only hoping that she was feeling it like I was and we could just kiss forever.
We leaned it and kissed. Her kiss was intoxicating. This time I could identify the feelings I felt with Grace but it was overwhelmingly stronger with Erika. It was love. I was fully in love with my own roommate Erika. When our 3 seconds were up she tried to pull away but I didn’t let her and I wanted it to last so much longer. Then she pulled away harder and we broke the kiss.
“Sorry Elise I’m just not feeling it like you.”
An uncomfortable silence filled the room.
“That’s ok.”
I was heart broken.
Next was Grace. She spun the bottle and it landed on Erika.
Apparently, Erika was feeling it with Grace because after the 3 seconds were up, they didn’t stop.
My heart shattered. The girl of my dreams was making out with my friend. I wanted the kiss to last longer but she chose Grace over me.
So we just continued to play the game without the two of them. I think I kissed everyone else in the room.
Finally, they stopped kissing.
“That concludes our night guys. Thanks for coming. Hopefully we can do this again soon!!!”
“Thanks Grace. Ready to leave Erika?” I asked.
“Nah thanks. I going to stay for a while and hangout with Grace.”
“Oh ok.” I said. As I left I could see they started to kiss again.
When I got back to the room, I cried. And when Erika didn’t come back, I knew what had happened. She and Grace were still kissing and probably more. I was finally able to cry myself to sleep with a broken heart.
---The Next Day---
I woke up and was alone in my room. I saw a text from Erika saying she and Grace were getting breakfast off campus and that I shouldn’t wait up for her. I went to the dining hall and got my own breakfast alone. That’s how I felt after last night…completely alone.
After I went to class, I got back to the room and there was Erika and Grace sitting and talking on her bed. I got the signal from Erika to leave. We made up a signal to leave in case we wanted to be alone with a guy (or a girl in this case) so I said I’m going to the library to study. I knew why she wanted to be alone. I’m not stupid but I just didn’t want to accept it.
I tried to go to the library and study but I just couldn’t focus. A little while later Erika texted me and told me it was ok to come back. She had to go to class.
When I got back her bed was all messy. My suspicions were true. It smelled like sex. My world literally shattered.
Instead of feeling sad, I used it to my advantage. Since Erika was in class and it still smelled like sex, I should masturbate thinking about Erika.
I striped off my clothes and thought about Erika eating out Grace with slow circles on my clit. Then I thought about Grace eating out Erika and I sped up and not long after I exploded as my orgasm hit me. Strongest of my life.
After that, it was a normal routine. I was asked to leave, then when I was alone, I would masturbate thinking about the two of them together. It was perfect but that only lasted for a month or two. I still wanted more. Then, like a god send, a perfect opportunity presented itself.
I was alone in my room doing homework. There was a knock at the door. It was Grace.
“Hey Grace. Looking for Erika? She isn’t here. She has a study group for the next 2 hours but that was about an hour ago, so she won’t be too much longer. You’re welcome to come in and wait.”
“Ok that sounds great. Thanks!”
I did homework for a little bit but then I had to speak up.
“Ok I can’t take it anymore. I felt something when we kissed.”
The look on her face was a mixture of shock and acceptance.
She stepped closer to me.
“Me too. It was like we were meant to kiss.”
And like magnets meeting, we kissed again. I felt strong electricity flowing between us and that feeling from our first kiss again, but it was so much stronger this time.
I pulled away.
“This is wrong. You’re with Erika.”
“She doesn’t have to know and plus we aren’t a thing. We are just friends with benefits. Plus, you said 2 hours right?”
“Yeah, but like I said, that was over an hour ago. She’ll probably be done in 30 minutes.
“Then let’s do something about these feelings right here right now. You with me?”
I couldn’t say no. Also, I did have feelings for Grace as well. But my true feelings were for Erika but Grace’s offer was too good to pass up.
“Alright but I’m a little nervous. I’ve never done more than kiss a girl before so go easy on me.”
“You’re going to love it don’t worry!” she assured me.
Our lips met again but it was more intense than before. It’s like they were glued together. They would not even separate when we moved to my bed. Before I knew it, we were full on making out on my bed.
Our lips and bodies were connected through electricity like a circuit flowing through us. It shot up my spine and surged all throughout my body.
“You ready?” she asked in a soft tone.
“Yes.” I said just above a whisper.
“Alright. Just sit back and relax.” Keeping her soft tone.
I closed my eyes. I felt light soft kisses on my neck and that made me shiver. As she moved down, they got harder. Before I knew it, she was hardcore sucking on my neck.
Next, she slowly lifted up my top and threw it to the side. She was marveled at my tits. Her eyes were super wide.
“Wow I love your tits. Why would you hide these?” she asked with a hint of humor.
“Well, apparently, I don’t need to anymore around you.” I said with a chuckle.
She starting sucking on my tits and that made me lightly clench my bed sheets. I didn’t know it could feel so good. She sucked my nipple into her mouth and flicked it around with her tongue. Then she would release it and do it again. I was trying so hard to not moan so no one would hear us. I grabbed my pillow and put it over my mouth. Then she moved on to my second nipple and repeated the process. It was a feeling like nothing else.
Then she gave slow kisses on my skin down my chest to my stomach until she made it to my soaking wet pussy. She slowly removed my panties and threw them on the floor.
“You ready?”
I took a deep breath.
“I’m ready.”
“Good because it wasn’t even a question.” She said with joking intent and she gave me that smile that I saw the first day I met her. A smile filled with happiness and love. That is how I know she could not and would not ever hurt me. Also, she could see in my eyes that I was ready and then I closed them.
I waited and waited and waited and it felt like an eternity. Then it hit me like a freight train. With one long steady lick up my pussy, I almost came but I held it back. I clenched my bed sheets harder to contain the feelings. I wanted it to last as long as possible. She went to work but went slowly as she knew it was my first time. She kept doing long and steady licks to warm me up. Then she moved up to my clit and did slow circles around it. Then she started to suck on it, and I clenched harder and bit my tongue.
Then, her grand finale; She plunged her tongue deep inside me and I came…hard! My legs got stiff and were shaking as I moaned and screamed into my pillow, but she didn’t stop. She was giving me orgasm after orgasm and she only stopped when I pushed her head away. I finally came back down to earth from my orgasmic high.
I never knew I could feel this good, relaxed, and, to be honest, whole. This was so much better than what I did by myself. That was to fill an empty void with nothingness and loneliness. When I did it myself it felt like water cascading over me like a shower, but this was like a waterfall crashing down on me with incredible force.
When I finally had the strength to open my eyes, there she was. Grace herself lying right next to me.
“Well? What did you think?”
I smiled with pure joy and bliss. “Un-fucking-believable. How do you know how to do this?”
“Oh silly Elise. I’m bisexual. I’ve had many girlfriends. After all these years going back to high school and you never knew? I introduced some of them to you and said ‘girlfriend’.”
“But that’s what all girls say when they introduce a friend like ‘Hey girlfriend what’s up!’ But now the whole Erika thing makes sense. At first I thought it was just because of the party and the alcohol or a friends with benefits thing but it all makes sense now.”
“Well, now you know. How long until Erika gets back?”
“I would say any minute now, so you need to leave immediately.”
“Ok. Remember, this stays between us. Maybe if you keep your promise we can do it again so you can return the favor!” she said with a coy smile on her face.
“Will do. I got to get back to homework. See you later Grace!”
“See ya Elise!”
She closed the door and left. As soon as she left I opened a window to air out the room. Erika can never know about this. We have the whole year together and I don’t want to betray her trust in the first month.
The whole rest of the day I couldn’t concentrate. It was even worse when Erika came back. I couldn’t even make eye contact with her. I felt so guilty.
“Hey Elise. What have you been up to?”
“Just homework and stuff. The usual.”
“Ok cool. I’m going to Grace’s. Wanna come?”
“Nah I got work to do but thanks for the invite.”
“Ok. Don’t work too hard. Remember, work hard, play hard.”
“Ok. Maybe I’ll stop by later.”
“There you go! See you soon.” And she closed the door and left.
Phew she didn’t know.
Grace and I continued to have sex. Whenever Erika was out, we would meet in her room or mine and just fuck. Friends with benefits just like Grace and Erika except with Grace and I there were no feelings. It was just plain sex.
But it was hard. I still had strong feelings for Erika. After about 5 months of Grace and me I knew it was time. I had to tell Erika how I felt. I had only imagined it before, but I had to know what it really felt like. I really couldn’t take it anymore. It was literally eating away at me inside. I felt like I was going to explode. She had to know.
I had the perfect opportunity. Erika and I were alone in our room after a pep rally and I knew Grace couldn’t interrupt us because she was out of town. I took a deep breath and turned around and faced Erika who was sitting on her bed.
My god she looked beautiful. Her silky hair cascading and ending at her shoulders, he perfect lips just needing to be kissed, he piercing blue eyes, and her perfect figure.
“Hey Erika. Can we talk?”
“Sure Elise what’s up?”
“Well this is hard to say so bear with me as I struggle through this.”
“Take your time I’ve got nowhere to be.”
“Ok thanks. Listen, the things I’ve been going through recently has made my life a little rough. I’ve met a lot of people, boys and girls, and some I’m friends with but no one I’ve had a deep connection with. No one seemed right for me and what I’m looking for is a deep emotional relationship. I personally think, the best things, the richest things, aren’t supposed to come easily. And sometimes the things that make the most sense make sense when everything else doesn’t. The thing is though, I’ve already found they special someone. All they have to do is say yes.” I said as I poured my heart out to her.
“Really? Who is it? Maybe I can help you. I promise I won’t tell.”
I just looked down at the floor and then back up to her eyes. I saw her smile turn to quivering lips as she started to tear up as she ran out of the room.
I felt terrible. I just made my roommate and best friend cry. I just laid back on my bed and started to cry myself. I’m pretty sure I just destroyed our friendship. I didn’t even know if she would come back. Seconds turned to minutes that turned to hours and soon it was nighttime. What if she never came back? How could I go on without her?
Right before I went to bed there was a knock at my door. I flew towards the door and Grace was there. My heart sank.
“Hey Elise. Do you know where Erika is? I’ve been trying to reach her all day and I can’t find her anywhere.”
“Nope. She left my room around noon and hasn’t come back since. Wait, I think I know where she is!”
“Awesome. Let me come with you.”
“No, I need to go alone. There is something we need to talk about alone.”
There is a statue at the top of the hill that overlooks the entire campus. We walked up there one day and said its really pretty and a great place to go when you need to be alone and get some peace and quiet since it’s a pretty long hike. I grabbed my flashlight and headed out.
Half and hour later I finally reached the top of the hill and there sitting below the statue looking out over the campus was Erika.
I walked up next to her.
“Hey Erika. Can I sit here?”
No answer.
“I’m going to anyways.” And I sat down next to her.
We both sat there in silence for about 5 minutes before I decided to speak up.
“Listen Erika I’m sorry. I meant everything I said and I fell in love the moment you stepped into our room.”
“Elise stop.” She whispered.
“I had these feeling for a while and I didn’t know how long I could keep them in.”
“Stop!!!” she basically screamed.
I sat there in silence.
“Do you know what you have put me through these past couple of hours? I have cried 5 times in the past 5 hours. I keep thinking how this could have happened. I didn’t send any mixed signals or drop any hints or anything so I don’t know how this could happen.”
“I didn’t say you liked me. I said I love you. It was nothing you did. It’s how I feel.”
“Leave me be right now. I’ll come back and talk to you when I’m ready.”
“Ok if that’s what you want.” I said and I headed back down to our room.
I couldn’t help but think about what I put her through. I never meant to hurt her. I just wanted to tell how I felt and hopefully she would have felt the same way.
At about 3:00 am, Erika came back.
“Listen, I have thought about this and I have a proposition for you. If we have sex once, let me be clear ONCE, will you be satisfied and let this whole thing go?”
I was jaw dropped at this proposition.
“Yes yes yessss!!! I will let this go and we will put it all behind us. Just one time.”
“Just one time.” She said with a slight excitement in her voice.
“How do you want to do this Elise?”
I leapt towards her and placed a kiss on her soft perfect lips that have been taunting me for so long. It was even better than I could have ever expected. It was like our lips were melted together by lust.
I started to take off her shirt and she lifted her arms to let me do it. She took mine off as well it is felt like a dream and I didn’t want it to end.
We slowly stumbled our way to my bed careful not to break our lustful kiss and we made it and the kiss became more passionate and intense. I could literally feel the lustful energy coursing throughout my entire body. It was like I was on fire and I think our lips were because even when we started to take our bras off, they were fused together and unbreakable. We kissed like that for hours.
The fusing of our numb lips broke.
“I can’t feel my lips.” I said.
“I guess it is true that you can kiss so much that you can no longer feel the kisses haha.” She said while chuckling.
“Should we press pause and eat something, so we have energy for phase 2?” she asked.
“No fucking way we’ve come too far. I don’t want you to change your mind.”
I pushed her back on the bed and started to suck on her neck getting a soft moan from my true love. The harder I sucked the louder the moans got. Then I started to nibble and that really got her going.
“You have to be quiet! It’s only 6:00 am. People are still sleeping.” And I shoved a pillow over her face, but I was still proud that I was causing moans so loud that we had to use a pillow to stifle them.
Then the moment I had been waiting for. I moved down to her perfect, perky breasts that I have only seen a couple times and now I get to suck on them? Is this a dream? Is this really happening? I snapped out and it and thought I should get to work.
I moved to her first nipple and sucked it into my mouth. She kept moaning to tell me I was doing a good job. I kept sucking and licking her nipple to warm her up and her skin was so soft I could have licked forever.
I slowly released my mouth from her nipple, and I knew it was time. I slowly placed soft kisses down her body down to her wet pussy. I slowly peeled off her panties. Her pussy was dripping wet and smell was intoxicating making my mind all fuzzy and my vision blurry.
I finally knew I could do this. I placed one long lick up her pussy coating my tongue with her juices. My god I thought I was going to faint she tasted so amazing. She moaned to tell me she approved.
I kept on thinking it was a dream and I was going to wake up, but I kept licking to know I was not dreaming. This was real. This was reality. I never thought this would happen, but it’s happening.
I kept doing slow licks to not make her cum too fast. I knew it would happen only once, so I needed it to last as long as possible. Her moans were telling me to keep going. I knew it couldn’t wait so I moved up to her clit. I could feel she needed to cum.
So, I sucked super hard on clit. She moaned and arched her back. I knew I was doing a good job. I kept sucking and licking and so I shoved a finger in and that really got her going. I could feel her tensing up, so I knew she was close. I knew it was finally time for her to cum. So, I replaced my finger with my tongue and shoved my tongue in as far and I could, and she exploded and literally screamed and luckily the pillow did its job to make it quieter as it was 6:00 am. She was squirming and shaking, and I knew she was enjoying herself. I held her close to calm her down. She finally stopped shaking and opened her eyes and she looked up at me.
“Wow. Oh my gosh. I passed out. That was hands down the best orgasm I’ve ever had. Thank you.” She said above a whisper.
“You’re welcome sweetheart. I think you need to hold up your end of the bargain now.”
“I guess you’re right. Remember one time and that’s it.” She reminded me.
“One time.” I said with a smile.
“Ok.” She smiled.
She slowly laid me back.
“Put this pillow over your mouth. I’ve known to cause some pretty loud moans. Just ask Grace.” She said with a smile.
“As you wish my dear.” And I put the pillow over my mouth.
With the pillow over my face I couldn’t see, and I couldn’t tell what was taking so long.
I took the pillow off my face and there was Erika shaking with fear.
“Are you ok?” I said as I hugged her.
“I need to be honest. When you just made love to me, I actually felt something. It was feelings for you, and I have the fear that if I start this with you, I won’t be able to stop. I said one time but if I go further with you, I know for a fact the feelings will get stronger and that won’t end well.”
“What’s wrong with that? That’s what we both want. To keep this going. I don’t see anything wrong with that.”
“We are roommates and we spend a huge amount of time together. Every time we are together, I won’t be able to control myself. I’ll always want to have sex and that’s not healthy. I will miss study groups and classes just to be with you.” She said with tears forming with her eyes.
“How about this. We save sex for the weekends. After homework and all work is done, we can spend intimate time together. How does that sound?” I asked. I didn’t want to lose this, so I had to compromise.
She took a deep breath. “Ok. Let’s try it.”
I felt like I was about to scream but I didn’t want to not freak her out so I held it in.
“Yay! Thanks!”
“Do you still want me to satisfy your needs?”
“Yes please.”
That is when I had the best sex of my entire life. I had at least 4 orgasms. I fainted and she just kept going. She wanted to be sure I was satisfied. And I have to say I was more than satisfied.
“So how do you feel?” she asked lying next to me.
“Dead and completely satisfied. I hope this is something that will continue.” I replied but then something hit me. I was also sleeping with Grace, so I had to hide each relationship from each other. I had to juggle these two girls and they couldn’t figure out about each other.
As I kept thinking about it, I knew I had to drop one of them. But who? Erika was my true love and I knew she wanted this. But Grace, oh Grace was just amazing, and we could sleep together not just on the weekends. I knew I had to choose. Have limited sex with my true love, or endless sex with someone who is amazing. I was really in a pickle.
--A Week Later--
I took a week to think about it and I made my decision. I had to go with Erika. But I wanted one more sexual encounter with Grace so when Erika left for her class, I invited Grace over.
“Hey Grace.”
“Hey sexy thing. You ready to do this?”
“Yeah just one more thing. This has to be a last time for us. I’m getting really busy and I don’t think I can keep up with someone as sexually active as you.” I lied to her. I had to come up with something to make sure we couldn’t continue this.
She looked down and then looked up.
“Are you being serious? This is about to end?”
“Yes, I’m so sorry but we get to have sex one more time. Let’s make it a good one.”
“Ok fine.”
And we made love for over an hour.
While we were laying there naked and free the door opened and there was Erika. Her face only showed one emotion; shock.
“Ok Erika I can explain.”
“No need. This has always been a fantasy of mine. Let’s all have sex together.”
And we did. We swapped eating each other out and sucking on each other’s nipples and we had orgasmic bliss until the sun set over that beautiful day.
“Girls, this has been amazing. Let’s make this a normal thing. What do you girls think?”
“For sure!” they both said in unison.
“Ok. Let’s sleep.”
And we did and I no longer needed to dream about either Erika or Grace because I finally got what I always wanted in room 268.